{
 "id": "basics-u3-l3-2-q09",
 "question": "What is the difference between discipline and punishment?",
 "answer": "Punishment and discipline are not the same thing. Punishment is retribution for sin—and Jesus Christ bore all of ours on the cross, so God never punishes His children. Discipline is corrective; when we get out of line, God disciplines us for the single purpose of getting us back into fellowship and into the place of blessing. Even when it is severe—a scourging that is extremely painful—it is always carried out in love, because His intention is never to punish us but to restore us.",
 "url": "/faq/what-the-difference-between-discipline-and-punishment/",
 "unit": 3,
 "lesson": "3-2",
 "lesson_title": "The Danger—Spiritual Retreat/Reversion",
 "question_type": "comprehension",
 "tier": 1,
 "faq_class": "review",
 "aeo_questions": [
  "What is the difference between God's correction and punishment of believers?",
  "How does God show love to His children through painful corrections?",
  "What is the purpose of God's discipline of believers and how is it different from punishment?"
 ],
 "topic_anchor": null,
 "derivation": "voice-rewritten",
 "source_authority": "authoritative",
 "author": "Gene Cunningham",
 "book": "The Basics",
 "source": {
  "doc_id": "btbm-01-TheBasics-8-10-24",
  "ref": "The Basics, Unit 3, Lesson 3-2 - The Danger—Spiritual Retreat/Reversion (Review q9)",
  "book_page": [
   129,
   142
  ],
  "flipbook_page": 141,
  "view_url": "/library/the-basics/unit-3/lesson-3-2"
 },
 "scripture": [
  {
   "display": "2 Samuel 15-17",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    141
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Ephesians 4:17-19",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    141
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "2 Timothy 2:15",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    142
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Hebrews 3:7-15",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    141
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "2 Peter 3:18",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    142
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Jeremiah 2:13",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    143
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "1 Corinthians 11:31",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    144
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Hebrews 10:38",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    142
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Hebrews 12:1-4",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    144
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "Hebrews 12:5-11",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    144
   ]
  },
  {
   "display": "1 John 5:16",
   "osis": null,
   "book_pages": [
    144
   ]
  }
 ],
 "topics": [
  "Blessing",
  "Cross",
  "Discipline",
  "Disciplines",
  "Fellowship"
 ],
 "topics_context": [
  "Ahithophel",
  "Absalom",
  "attitude toward Bible",
  "David",
  "Judas",
  "Judging"
 ],
 "printed_pages": [
  129,
  130,
  131,
  132,
  133,
  134,
  135,
  136,
  137,
  138,
  139,
  140,
  141,
  142
 ],
 "related": {
  "ranked": [
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-discipline",
    "topic_idf_score": 9.992,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Death",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines",
     "The Sin Unto Death"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 1,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u3-l3-2-q08",
    "topic_idf_score": 9.992,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 1,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-promises-of-god",
    "topic_idf_score": 10.033,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Blessing",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Blessing",
     "Disciplines",
     "Exodus generation",
     "Faith",
     "Faith-Rest",
     "Fellowship",
     "Learning",
     "Peace",
     "Prayer",
     "Promises",
     "Rest",
     "Spiritual maturity",
     "The Faith-Rest Technique",
     "Trials",
     "fellowship with God",
     "promises of God"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-disciplines",
    "topic_idf_score": 6.89,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Applying doctrine",
     "Disciplines",
     "Doctrine",
     "Faith",
     "Faith-Rest",
     "Fellowship",
     "Peace",
     "Prayer",
     "Promises",
     "Rest",
     "Service",
     "The Faith-Rest Technique",
     "Trials",
     "fellowship with God"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u5-l5-3-q09",
    "topic_idf_score": 6.89,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Disciplines"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Disciplines",
     "Fellowship",
     "Mind",
     "Peace",
     "Prayer",
     "Promises",
     "Rest",
     "Trials",
     "fellowship with God",
     "promises of God"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-impl-blessing-and-reward",
    "topic_idf_score": 6.698,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Blessing",
     "Discipline"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Blessing",
     "Discipline",
     "Glory",
     "Ministry",
     "Reward",
     "Righteousness",
     "Self-discipline",
     "Spiritual blessing",
     "Spirituality",
     "Testing",
     "categories of Blessing",
     "categories of Reward",
     "crown of Righteousness"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-the-virgin-birth",
    "topic_idf_score": 5.822,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Abraham",
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Isaiah",
     "Mary",
     "Matthew",
     "Redemption"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u3-l3-5-q10",
    "topic_idf_score": 5.822,
    "why": "topic",
    "shared_topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline"
    ],
    "topics": [
     "Advanced Doctrine",
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Doctrine",
     "Growth",
     "Hebrew words for Faith",
     "Hero of faith",
     "Isaiah",
     "Paul",
     "Salvation",
     "Wisdom"
    ],
    "shared_verse_count": 0,
    "same_lesson": false
   }
  ],
  "same_lesson": [
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q01",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q02",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q03",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q04",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q05",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q06"
  ],
  "shares_scripture": [
   "basics-canon-carnality",
   "basics-canon-soul",
   "basics-canon-bible-study",
   "basics-u3-l3-2-q08",
   "basics-canon-discipline"
  ],
  "shares_topic": [
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-promises-of-god",
    "score": 10.033,
    "topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Blessing",
     "Disciplines"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-discipline",
    "score": 9.992,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u3-l3-2-q08",
    "score": 9.992,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline",
     "Disciplines"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-disciplines",
    "score": 6.89,
    "topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Disciplines"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u5-l5-3-q09",
    "score": 6.89,
    "topics": [
     "Fellowship",
     "Disciplines"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-impl-blessing-and-reward",
    "score": 6.698,
    "topics": [
     "Blessing",
     "Discipline"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-the-virgin-birth",
    "score": 5.822,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-u3-l3-5-q10",
    "score": 5.822,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Discipline"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-canon-religion",
    "score": 5.409,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Blessing"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "basics-faq-jesus-only-way",
    "score": 5.409,
    "topics": [
     "Cross",
     "Blessing"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "prev": "basics-u3-l3-2-q08",
  "next": "basics-u3-l3-2-q10",
  "prev_kind": "same",
  "next_kind": "same"
 }
}